10mm Vs 357 For Bear

Tom Gresham's Gun Talk 9. The 10mm does shoot "flatter" at distance shooting, but under 50 yards the accuracy of both is about the same. 357 stoked with hardcast heavy for caliber bullets in the woods. 40 caliber (the real version) and what draws me to the. The 10mm loaded to the gills and fired from a longer specialty barrel, can approach a hot loaded. I would consider the 10mm more of a caliber used in the back country for personal protection against 4 legged predators. 7x28mm vs Body Armor Today on Kentucky Ballistics we shoot some soft body armor with 9mm, 357 Sig, 10mm and 5. 20 Best 10mm Handguns For Sale in 2019. He shouldn't have tried to shoot the spinal column through the front, go straight to the brain pan. Video Surveillance Of Bears and Boars: The rebirth of the 10mm Auto. When I pack meat in Montana, I carry a 44mag or 45colt w/ heavy loads. 45 has a heavier grain bullet but the. 5" BBL, Satin Nickel Finish. In reality you are highly unlikely to have a bear problem. 45 ACP for deer hunting - is the 10mm significantly better? We touched on this briefly in a previous discussion, but I thought I would go a little more in-depth. The 10mm Auto, or just 10mm for short delivers a sizable 556 ft/lbs of energy similar to. 45 LC within the Hunting forums, part of the Firearm Forum category; I'm very interested in this thread. 357SIG round, which I can convert to with a simple barrel change-out. 357 are compared quite often, when the bullet weight is 200 grain (for instance) and a standard Glock 20 is compared to a 6". Each caliber's specially developed load has been expertly crafted from only the best of components. The same is true for the rounds from Speer, Federal, and Remington. Black Aces Tactical Side by Side. The 10mm is a newcomer in the hunting world, but has become a big player in the market for bear hunters or anyone needing extra power. 45ACP loaded with hot rounds. Good thing about the 10mm you could use. 5" barrel and 10 mm are 5" barrel. 357 magnum. I am new to the site, and have a question. 45 has a heavier grain bullet but the. 40 caliber (the real version) and what draws me to the. But the supporting data isn't out there to confirm it. 15 Rd - Israeli Made - Good Surplus Condition - With Police Star Markings. The 10mm beats the 357 for me just because of the light rail and night sights. I prefer the 125-grain JHP in the. Matter of choice but the reality is the. 357 Sig with a b. Since its development in the. Defense Against Bears with Pistols: 97% Success rate, 37 incidents by Caliber. As with any cartridge debate, there are bound to be die-hard supporters and fanboys who simply swear by their bullet of choice. Will a 10MM stop a black bear or should I go with a 357 Magnum Hello everyone I was wondering if any of you guys ever encounter a black bear while you was hunting with your 10MM, & if you had to put it down what was the results, also which would be better a 10MM or a 357 Magnum in 1911. Definitely not suitable for grizzly/brown. But If a 357 is a gun that fits the need, the GP100 is a dandy. trying to force their dreams on the reality of Alaska. Thank you for visiting SGAmmo. It charges, and you have time to pull out your sidearm. 8” of weight and reduces muzzle flip and felt recoil. The 10mm beats the 357 for me just because of the light rail and night sights. 10mm for Grizzly protection - page 1 - 10mm This makes me laugh at the 10mm or 357 being considered a woods gun. The bear is 7 seconds form being on top of you. 357 will break a neck or shoulder & penetrate a heart. Looking for a pack gun, pistol, carried in shoulder or chest holster, in Kodiak country, Alaska. I’d say an 8-shot N frame S&W in 357 or a 1911 style 10mm with long slide. A common theme you will run into when people are discussing the 10mm Auto is that it falls into an awkward weird little crevice somewhere between the performance of a. I decided to run a 10mm head to head with a. 0 inch barrel will fit any and all Bond Arms Derringers. 41 Magnum rounds. incarnation; the. for several years now with 180gr JHP from DoubleTap ammo. 357 Magnum rounds are still loaded considerably hotter than the. 44 Magnum or other larger cartridge. The Case For The 357 Magnum “The All-Around Handgun Cartridge?” Phil Shoemaker once wrote a very controversial article for Handloader magazine in which he confessed that his personal choice for a backup handgun, while guiding clients for Brown Bear, was a Smith and Wesson Model 60 in 357 Magnum. Last time I was in bear country, I had a. The bear is 7 seconds form being on top of you. I have been guiding brown bear hunters and fishermen and bear photographers from our homestead within Becharof National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska for 33 years and have had numerous close encounters with bears. All the ballistics from all manufacturers, finally in one place. Better For Bear. In the YouTube video below, Elijah pits the two middleweight cartridges against one another and gives us some empirical data. The 10mm Auto, or just plain 10mm, is an example of a cartridge that was a good idea but had a rough start. 357 will break a neck or shoulder & penetrate a heart. 44 Magnum (mid-weight loads) ballistics. Started by john james , Mar 22 2015 If I were hunting with a handgun it would probably be a Glock 10MM for close range for the. it depends on the load (buffalo bore has some good loads for this), shot placement, and size (hide thickness) of the bear. If memory serves, the case capacity of the 10mm is about 24 vs. Owner of Buffalo Bore Tim Sundles on Heavy 10mm Ammunition: The Buffalo Bore Heavy 10mm ammo is the result of many years of customers requests that we produce several such loads for the 10mm. but on a serious note. 45's and 9mm. You really cannot compare a 10mm to the other rounds, it is a very good hunting round and has taken everything up to Grizzly bears but comparing it to a. HSM only uses the best in domestic components, from the primer to the bullet head you can be assured that they are all premium and combined in such a manner as to provide the Ventura Munitions customer the most in Custom Ammunition. 40 S&W and. If you are looking for bulk ammunition, you came to the right website!We pride ourselves on offering only the best deals to the most serious shooters for bulk handgun ammo, bulk rifle ammo, bulk shotgun ammo, and bulk rimfire ammo. HELP within the Hunting forums, part of the Firearm Forum category; You can't go wrong here with either one. That doesn't mean that It's ineffective, just that there has to be a cutoff somewhere. I would use them for different purposes. 357 Magnum is the way to go. 45 colt vs 357 mag for bear. Both are VERY tough to buy ammo for. 357 caliber revolvers to 9mm semi-automatics to 10mm (after the 1986 Miami shootout), then to. When in bear country, magnum is the key word. Assured indeed of the bear's demise, Jim phoned Alaska troopers while Montana and the dog inspected the erstwhile invader. hand gun hunting – the 10mm, and tupperware pistols Posted on May 29, 2013 by MikeH In the earlier post about hunting with semi-auto pistols, it was pointed out that the. I almost put this in the hunting section since many people who hunt consider the 10mm an option but there are also many people who choose a 10mm or 45 for "woods gun" for protection against bears. it depends on the load (buffalo bore has some good loads for this), shot placement, and size (hide thickness) of the bear. "keep in mind that reloading manuals often times report loads in different length barrels - for example - my hornady manual loads for the. Usually they throw out that the 10mm ‘approaches’. com)-The 10mm Auto, sometimes referred to as the "357 of the Auto Pistol World", has experienced a resurgence of late. There are those who are adamant that. What makes the 10mm such an interesting (and to some, attractive) option is that there are no options in a semi-auto that are only a few ounces heavier/bigger than a 10mm that does the same thing with more power the way a. HSM’s Bear Load delivers incredible terminal performance on the biggest, angriest and most aggressive animals when it matters most. On the surface, the former produces slightly more energy than most. Typing your keyword including Gun-Shop Sig Sauer Elite Performance Ammunition 10mm Bear Buy Gun-Shop Sig Sauer Elite Performance Ammunition 10mm Bear Reviews : You finding where to buy Gun-Shop Sig Sauer Elite Performance Ammunition 10mm Bear for cheap best price. I would use them for different purposes. I have owned over the years delta elite. Time, technique, and plenty of practice is key to managing how one deals with the recoil and accuracy of both. 357 or the like is shoot anywhere on a bears torso then not only will you have a massive wound channel, but the gases from the pistol will also inflict major damage. 41 Magnum chambering at it's middle/lower-end performance levels. Just remember they say for Grizzly/Brown bear to file the front sight off so when the bear sticks it up your #/%& (where the sun don't shine) it won't hurt as much. Read Comments. 62X35mm 3 357 Magnum 3 357 Sig Sauer 2 380 Automatic. But in 1987, Colt released its Delta Elite, a 1911-style pistol chambered for the 10mm. 45 acp, and the 10mm was designed to replace the. In the YouTube video below, Elijah pits the two middleweight cartridges against one another and gives us some empirical data. 357 loads make the. Would a 10mm be my choice if I knew I was facing a pissed off griz? Taurus model 66 revolver. 357 Magnum is the way to go. 357 mag is considered minimal for bear defense. Still, perhaps the most popular handgun round for deer is the. Now, keep in mind Alaska authorities take a grim view of killing brown bears without good reason--like hunting or self-defense, for. When in bear country, magnum is the key word. I have been toying with the idea of the 10mm for a few years now. 10mm 19 30-30 Winchester 300 AAC Blackout-Whisper 7. 40 because of the difference in length. Ruger's GP100 Double-Action Centerfire Revolvers are renowned for dependability, accuracy and reliability. 10mm Auto vs. Guaranteed to be in stock + ready to ship. Still, perhaps the most popular handgun round for deer is the. The 10MM is approximately the equivalent of the 357 Magnum and should be good enough for cougars and 2 legged varmints along with the 357 magnum for this purpose. Arizona-(Ammoland. The grip diameter is more on a 10mm vs a. 357 magnum has a long track record of a mini-hand cannon for personal defense. Last time I was in bear country, I had a. If you searching for special discount you may need to searching when special time come or holidays. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare 10mm Auto vs. If you have medium to large hands you should find the larger grip comfortable. 10mm for Grizzly protection - page 1 - 10mm This makes me laugh at the 10mm or 357 being considered a woods gun. Developed primarily as a law enforcement pistol cartridge, the. If you are in dangerous bear country you need a high power rifle that will kill the bear before it has time to kill you. 40 S&W and 10mm Auto cartridges with these premium. Having taken a black bear with a. 357 magnum bear guns and bear loads. 357 is stuck in the. Full power 10mm sits between between the. Basically the hot 10mm rounds are about as powerful as the lightest. This was due to the excessive recoil which many to-be, and in the field LEO who scored poorly. has plenty of punch for deer-sized game. Video Surveillance Of Bears and Boars: The rebirth of the 10mm Auto. The original 10mm ballistics are alive and well with this round. About 200 fps or more. The 10mm Auto, itself the magnum-level mother cartridge of both the. I believe a heavy, hard. XTP: 1180 fps, 550 ft-lbs. com, heavy metal bullets can be used to reload, cast lead bullets are fun to shoot, shooting is fun to do many times, reloading saves money, reloading is more accurate than brand ammunition, buy cast lead bullets from heavy metal bullets, reload your idpa and ispc and uspsa reloads with heavy metal bullets, cast lead bullets make reloading. 357 Magnum used to be loaded at 43,000 cup or between 45,000 and 48,000 psi. You'll have to adjust the dies however they need to be for whichever it is you're reloading, regardless of whether they'll do 40 or 10mm. A search term that seems to bring a lot of people here is some combination of Grizzly Bear and. I couldn’t sell it. 41 Magnum chambering at it's middle/lower-end performance levels. 357 revolvers and a. 10mm/45ACP Barrels; This website contains products sold by and/or manufactured by Lone Wolf Distributors Inc. Welcome to BulkAmmo. On one hand, 10mm is only about two-thirds as powerful as. Today, I want to dig into those results a little bit and I also want to tackle the broader question of whether or not 10mm is a good choice for self-defense. I wouldn't bother with the 9MM, but, it might be possible that you could (with a new barrel) modify your 19 to use 357SIG which I think could be a good alternative and not require you to go out and buy a new gun; I'm no expert on Glocks but it might be. American shooters think the more rounds they throw, the better. The Sporting Arms and Ammunition Manufacturers' Institute (SAAMI) maximum pressure limit for the 10mm Auto is set at 37,500 psi (259 MPa). The Glock 20 has several big advantages that make it a great bear-defense gun. Can't decide between 10mm or 357mag. I am considering picking up either the Glock 29 or 23. SIG P220 10mm Ruger GP-100 WC 3” Advertised barrel length 5” 3” Actual barrel bearing surface 3. 357 at the time - must be good, right? Then I got a job which included performing necropsies on wild critters - including black and grizzly bears. 38 Super have good track records against vehicles. And with a heavier bullet, the. Additional Information Critical Defense® Lite. 357 is certainly good enough to protect mine. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare 10mm Auto vs. Shop our vast selection and save! Pros glock 10mm vs 357 magnum Aesthetically Pleasing, Easy To Install, Good Value, Safe, Tough; glock 10mm vs 357 magnum Best Uses Competitive Shooting, Hunting, Self Defense, Tactical, Target Practice. 44 magnum for bear defense? Scenario: Your are bowhunting in Montana. bear EXPERIENCE, especially from anyone who used a 10mm on a grizzly or brown and survived, and about terminal effects on the bear. 44 magnum as a grizzly bear defense sidearm in Alaska. 29 inches for the. Technologically advanced powders push the premium, hard-cast bullets at significantly higher velocities for terminal energy superior to standard loads. The 10mm has a SAAMI limit of 40,000 psi; the. I carry a. It appears, in short, the best 10mm load in the best 10mm handgun may "kill" a black bear -- eventually -- but it can't necessarily be counted on to "stop" one reliably. 357mag and 10mm for protection against large animal I have heard either 357mag or 100mm is the minimum you need against large carnivores. 357 - my "bear" protection, SHTF, gun. Comparisons: 10mm vs. 357 magnum was marginal and not recommended unless you had nothing bigger. jacketed hollow points (JHPs) and jacketed soft points (JSPs) both can be great man. In this sequel to "Bears versus Guns", James revisits his earlier decision to carry a. is still the 'boss' at 150 yards!. However, I've seen a video of a park ranger shooting an attacking grizzly, at bear wrestling range, repeatedly with a. I would think a. 357 Magnum vs. Typing your keyword including Gun-Shop Sig Sauer Elite Performance Ammunition 10mm Bear Buy Gun-Shop Sig Sauer Elite Performance Ammunition 10mm Bear Reviews : You finding where to buy Gun-Shop Sig Sauer Elite Performance Ammunition 10mm Bear for cheap best price. 357 gets a 4" vented barrel. Owner of Buffalo Bore Tim Sundles on Heavy 10mm Ammunition: The Buffalo Bore Heavy 10mm ammo is the result of many years of customers requests that we produce several such loads for the 10mm. Having taken a black bear with a. Black Aces Tactical Side by Side. We accept returns. But the semi auto in 10mm is a good choice for a general woods gun. As a teen I spent summers with my siblings at my dad's in Alaska, and there'd be reports of bear maulings quite often. The selection of firearms chambered in 10mm is. No effect on the bear! You might feel more comfortable with the 10mm but I honestly feel you would be safer with the bear spray; the 10mm might just make her angry - the spray could disable her. Luckily most manufacturers offer their own special lines of JSP ammo, and this can take care of that problem. It's great for competition. The 10mm with a proper 10mm load is around similar ballistics to a. 44 Mag, in 300 gr. 357 Sig, and other less popular caliber choices is ammo cost. 357 most often wins the numbers game hands down. In territory that could prove to be treacherous in a heartbeat, it pays to be ever-vigilant and always ready. 45ACP, 10mm and the. I have both a 44 and a couple 10mm's plus several 357's. 45acp Around here you dont see 10mm or 357 sig on many ammo shelves - It'll kill deer and bear but not humans?. People will claim the. What makes the 10mm such an interesting (and to some, attractive) option is that there are no options in a semi-auto that are only a few ounces heavier/bigger than a 10mm that does the same thing with more power the way a. As Wwf stated the 10mm rounds are more expensive and may be tougher to find depending on locality. As a good example the 10mm and. I certainly think there is no need to carry a 12 ga shotgun out backpacking in most of the U. The 10mm does shoot "flatter" at distance shooting, but under 50 yards the accuracy of both is about the same. 357 are very close. Those that are successful in Alaska are those who are flexible, and allow the reality of life in Alaska to shape their dreams, vs. Especially when shooting hard cast or other non-expanding bullets, the. It's great for competition. We preferred two 180-grain rounds with great penetration. The bear is 7 seconds form being on top of you. for your specific needs, the 10mm would be the better choice. The 10mm Auto, itself the magnum-level mother cartridge of both the. What's The Difference? 10mm vs. It may work fine for a treed or scared bear -- but it's too iffy for an attacking. 357 magnum has a long track record of a mini-hand cannon for personal defense. Both were designed for semi-automatic handguns, both use a projectile that has a diameter of 355/1000 of an inch, and with modern bullet designs, i. The 10mm Auto is simply another choice in cartridges among a vast array of already existing cartridges and of cartridges yet to be introduced. 44 magnum is even better if you prefer something bigger and a wheelgun. 357 fired from a 4" barrel. 357 revolvers and a. 40 caliber) bullet is. Seriously, according to an article in the August 2018 American Rifleman ( "Nine Lives of the 10mm Auto" by Jeremiah Knupp) Denmark has issued 10mm pistols to their Sirius Dog Sled Patrols for polar bear defense since 2000. The lower recoiling 357 or 10mm is easier for me to shoot well without flinching, especially when they are all loaded with heavy for caliber hardcast bullets. a 10mm is a fucking mouse to a bear. The 357/45 Grizzly WinMag. In this sequel to "Bears versus Guns", James revisits his earlier decision to carry a. The bear is 7 seconds form being on top of you. 357 for the simple reason I can reach out a little farther with it accurately than the. 44 Mag revolvers a big, bulky guns, and, though fine weapons, many have fragile target typesights and the lockwork of a double action is complex. 45-70 Loads. I would like to hear about REAL 10mm vs. 357 magnum has a long track record of one-shot stops on attackers of all types. Due to the 9mm caliber's popularity, this article is going to mainly give the strengths and weaknesses of the 10mm in comparison with the 9mm version so that one can be able to make an informed decision, whether the 10mm is also a viable option or not. The gun jammed. 10mm vs 40 Smith & Wesson. I found the test guns used for verification is an 8 inch. And with a heavier bullet, the. He shouldn't have tried to shoot the spinal column through the front, go straight to the brain pan. I would think a. This helps novice shooters that need to shoot more ammo to develop muscle memory. 45 ACP I think I would go with the. 41 Remington Magnum mirrors that of the 10mm Auto. 357 Magnum energy range, but the bullet performs well. 45 super vs 10mm ballistics, 45 super vs 10mm for bear gun, 45 super vs 357 magnum, 45 super vs 44 mag, 45 super vs bear. In this case, I'd carry the most powerful round that you can shoot quickly & accurately. 300 Remington Ultra Mag. The development of the 10mm cartridge is actually an interesting story that dates back to the 1970s. Against a bear, penetration is the name of the game. Towsley , Tyler Freel , and John B. 357 SIG round is going to be any more effective vs bears than. com and compare similar bullet. 30 Winchester, and he’d bring up the rear with a 12 gauge. 44 Remington Magnum. 357 are compared quite often, when the bullet weight is 200 grain (for instance) and a standard Glock 20 is compared to a 6". trying to force their dreams on the reality of Alaska. I found the test guns used for verification is an 8 inch. 357 Magnum VS. 44magnum during ballistics test, however a handgun would not be my first choice for bear protection, especially grizzly. And with a heavier bullet, the. The 9mm would be used in an urban environment for personal protection against 2 legged predators. Those that are successful in Alaska are those who are flexible, and allow the reality of life in Alaska to shape their dreams, vs. 40 S&W or 9mm and the performance of larger calibers such as the. 10mm 19 30-30 Winchester 300 AAC Blackout-Whisper 7. Give your derringer a different look or expand the caliber capability of you favorite conceal and carry firearm. 10mm should be good out to about 250mif you are. I used to really want a 10mm. 357: This is gonna be a lot better than the 45ACP, but most people experienced with bears will tell you that carrying a. 357 Magnum used to be loaded at 43,000 cup or between 45,000 and 48,000 psi. Good compromise load for self-defense in bear country. 357 has less recoil than 44 mag so in theory you would have a better chance of actually placing a good shot. If I had to pick between the. The 10 is often found using. hand gun hunting – the 10mm, and tupperware pistols Posted on May 29, 2013 by MikeH In the earlier post about hunting with semi-auto pistols, it was pointed out that the. The 10mm has a SAAMI limit of 40,000 psi; the. 357 is stuck in the. 357 Magnum and yield less recoil than the. Several times, students have told me that they were interested in a handgun for hiking or camping; one that could protect them from wolves, boars, or bears, as well as the traditional two-legged varmints. The idea was for a high power, flat shooting, semi-auto cartridge that would run in a 1911-format pistol and basically deliver. And no, the 10mm would be far worse for a large bear charge as opposed to a. A 10mm will work against black bear with the right ammo. Both are VERY tough to buy ammo for. If memory serves, the case capacity of the 10mm is about 24 vs. but on a serious note. I would think a. 357 revolvers and a. It pretty much accepted that the 357 Magnum and 10mm are ballistic twins when shot from handguns but what about from a carbine? Wouldn't the 357 magnum get a bigger boost from the longer barrel since the 357 case is bigger and can take advantage of slower burning powders?. Would you rather have a. over penetration is not a concern with handguns and bears. 357 penetration at 22 inches. I would prefer hollow points to solids because when a bear is charging you he is headlong, so if I have to shoot him I would want to do as much damage as possible. The 10mm beats the 357 for me just because of the light rail and night sights. Except for case length, the. And if you're looking for self-defense for a grizzly bear, do consider the. Therefore, I choose to give the nod to the bigger bullet of the 10mm. I take it that means in case you need to, hunting ungulate with those two rounds is possible. Beginning shooters, as well as professionals, can shoot the low-velocity target or +P loads. glock 40 10mm vs bear is your source for Rebate Sale/Clearance at Gun Store parts and accessories. in my part of the world in SC any would do, 357, 10mm 45acp if I were in bear country bigger is better. Let's not go down the. The 10mm typically uses a 5. 357 revolvers and a. Would you rather have a. These owners love the power. Bears have been put down with. Here are the results of my experimentation. 357 mag or. Inferior metrics to hot 41 Remington Magnum or 357 Magnum rounds. Btw, thoughts on 9mm vs. "Stopping" bears with handgun or rifle cartridges. 41 Magnum chambering at it's middle/lower-end performance levels. The development of the 10mm cartridge is actually an interesting story that dates back to the 1970s. com Comparison shop for in-stock ammunition, guns, mags, and reloading at the lowest prices from over 100 online retailers all in one place: AmmoSeek. incarnation; the. 357) Use: Defense You will get some funny looks if you tell people you use a. Finding the Forgotten. 357 would penetrate a black bear skull, maybe even through the body on a smallish one. 357 Magnum load and below standard. A Brief History 10mm Auto. The bad news is a heart shot won't instantly stop a charging bear. The 10mm cartridge, over a wide power spectrum of loads, is slightly above the. Definitely not suitable for grizzly/brown. Of course, if you opt Glock for 10mm, you have the choice of shooting. The 10mm Auto, or just 10mm for short delivers a sizable 556 ft/lbs of energy similar to. 357 caliber revolvers to 9mm semi-automatics to 10mm (after the 1986 Miami shootout), then to. But If a 357 is a gun that fits the need, the GP100 is a dandy. 44 mag with twice as much energy and a heavier bullet and better SD. Tests against windshield glass and car doors proved that the high-velocity CorBon bullets did not deflect from their intended path and still expanded well into a. How to Pick the Right Sidearm for Backup Bear Protection Two experts square off on their picks for the ideal bear defense handgun By Will Brantley , Bryce M. incarnation; the. 45 ACP and. The Sporting Arms and Ammunition Manufacturers' Institute (SAAMI) maximum pressure limit for the 10mm Auto is set at 37,500 psi (259 MPa).